Catalogue of the Lyversberg Collection, Cologne 1837, nos.18, 19 and 20;

F. Kugler, Rheinreise, 1841, vol.2, p.312 (described as a fine example of the Cologne School from the early sixteenth century);

A. Springer, Köln Handbuch 1855, p.351;

E. Firmenich-Richartz, Bartholomaeus Bruyn und seine Schule, 1891, p.83;

H. Reiners, Die Kölner Malerschule, Bonn 1925, pp.254-255, fig.284, note 282, as Cologne master, first half sixteenth century;

P. Clemen, Kunstdenkmahler der Stadt Köln, 1937, pp,107, 111;

Hjorst-Johs Tümmers, Die Altarbilder des alteren Bartholomaus Bruyn, 1964, pp.127-128;

Mark L. Evans and Brian Kennedy, Triptych of the Virgin and Child with Saints, Cologne School c.1510-20, Canberra: National Gallery of Australia 2001